Invitation to Participate
Workshop on
New Entrants versus Incumbents in Biotechnology: Lessons from Japan for the U.S.
Women's Faculty Club at the University of California-Berkeley
Berkeley, California, April 2, 1999
You are invited to participate in a workshop examining new evidence from Japan on the ability of incumbent firms to commercialize new scientific breakthroughs in bioscience. The workshop addresses how the Japanese experience can inform the U.S. community about likely impacts of shifting more of the total biotech activity in the U.S. from new biotech firms to large incumbent firms. With a merger wave well underway in the U.S., it is a good time to raise issues related to both commercialization by pre-existing firms and combinations of pre-existing and new biotech firms. Are scientists of very different ability associated with these different kinds of firms? Does the linkage to science change in some basic way? How are decisions made about strategy of the firm?
This small and informal workshop will explore what is known about these issues, including changes in the life cycle of an industry that may directly impact how commercialization takes place--slower pace of formation of new firms, slower entry rates by existing firms, less venture capital available to the industry, and a lower rate of going public (making venture capital investments less likely to pay off for the investors). We again can rely on a natural experiment, comparing Japan to the U.S., since in Japan most of the institutional constraints that operate only later in the industrial life cycle in the U.S. are operative right from the very beginning of the industry (e.g., little venture capital and low probability of going public).
The workshop will have four panels: one on entry into biotech in Japan of primarily incumbent firms, the second on university contributions to firm success in Japan, the third on innovation in incumbent firms within the framework of financial and societal institutions, and the last a mixed industry/government/academic panel on the general issues raised including the generalizability of the Japan results. Each panel except the last will be followed by a discussant; all panels will be followed by general discussion. Details of the content and participants are in the program which begins on the next page.
Pre-Registration is free and required to attend the workshop, have lunch, and obtain a day parking permit. If you wish to attend, please fax back the enclosed form. A map detailing how to get to the Women's Faculty Club at the University of California-Berkeley appears at the end of this document.
The workshop is sponsored by grants from The University of California Systemwide Biotechnology Research and Education Program and The Center for Global Partnership of The Japan Foundation. It is organized by the Center for International Science, Technology, and Cultural Policy in the UCLA School of Public Policy and Social Research, by the John M. Olin Center for Policy in The Anderson School at UCLA and by the Organizational Research Program of the Institute for Social Science Research at UCLA.
Workshop on
New Entrants versus Incumbents in Biotechnology: Lessons from Japan for the U.S.
Women's Faculty Club at the University of California-Berkeley
Berkeley, Califonia, April 2, 1999
8:00-8:20 Opening remarks
Susanne Huttner, Director, University of California Systemwide Biotechnology Research and Education Program
Kimberly van Ee, The Center for Global Partnership of The Japan Foundation
8:20-9:40 Session 1: Entry into Biotech in Japan
Chair: Susanne Huttner, Director, University of California Systemwide Biotechnology Research and Education Program
Strategies of Japanese Firms Entering the Biotechnology Industry -- Case Studies of
the Pharmaceutical Industry
Takuma Takahashi, Nomura Research Institute, and Shingo Kano, Nomura
Research Institute and the Research Center for Advanced Science and Technology, University
of Tokyo
Star Scientists, Institutions, and the Entry of Japanese Biotechnology Enterprises
Michael R. Darby and Lynne G. Zucker, UCLA & NBER
Listed Japanese Firms: Entry into Biotechnology and Stock Prices
Tsuyoshi Nakamura, University of Tokyo, Kazuo Ueda, Bank of Japan, Lynne G.
Zucker, UCLA & NBER, and Michael R. Darby, UCLA & NBER
Discussant: Irwin Feller, Graduate Program in Policy Analysis, Pennsylvania State University
General Discussion
9:40-10:00 Coffee Break
10:00-11:05 Session 2: Innovation in Incumbent Firms and Financial/Societal Institutions
Chair: Takuma Takahashi, Nomura Research Institute
Determinants of Embodied Technology Transfer from Stars to Firms: Japan and the U.S.
Lynne G. Zucker and Michael R. Darby, UCLA and NBER, and Maximo
Torero, Universidad del Pacifico
Biotech-venture as a Pure Innovation Agent and the Shortfall of the Japanese
Approach
Shingo Kano, Nomura Research Institute and the Research Center for Advanced
Science and Technology, University of Tokyo
Discussant: Susan Helper, Department of Economics, Case Western University & NBER
General Discussion
11:05-11:15 Short Coffee Break
11:15-12:20 Session 3: University Contributions to Firm Success
Chair: Lynne G. Zucker, UCLA & NBER
Capturing Technological Opportunity Via Japan's Star Scientists: Evidence from
Japanese Firms' Biotech Patents and Products
Lynne G. Zucker and Michael R. Darby, UCLA & NBER
Knowledge Spillovers in the Japanese Chemical Industry: Analysis of Patent Data
Tsuyoshi Nakamura, University of Tokyo, and Kazuo Ueda, Bank of Japan
Discussant: Lee Branstetter, Department of Economics, University of California, Davis
General Discussion
12:20-1:20 Lunch
1:20-2:30 Session 4: Incumbent Firms in the U.S.: Can We Generalize from Japan?
Moderator: Michael R. Darby, UCLA and NBER
Panelists:
Duke Bristow, Senior Fellow, Harold Price Center for Entrepreneurial Studies, Anderson Graduate School of Management, UCLA [formerly, Manager of Mergers and Acquisitions and Manager of Long Range Planning, Eli Lilly & Co.]
Maryellen Kelley, Advanced Technology Program, National Institute of Standards and Technology
Roger Noll, Department of Economics, Stanford University
Confirmed participants in bold.
Organized by the Center for International Science, Technology, and Cultural Policy in the UCLA School of Public Policy and Social Research, the John M. Olin Center for Policy in The Anderson School at UCLA and by the Organizational Research Program of the Institute for Social Science Research at UCLA.
Sponsored by: The University of California Systemwide Biotechnology Research and Education Program and The Center for Global Partnership of The Japan Foundation.
![]()
Workshop on
New Entrants versus Incumbents in Biotechnology: Lessons from Japan for the U.S.
Women's Faculty Club at the University of California-Berkeley
Berkeley, Califonia, April 2, 1999
Pre-Registration is free and required to attend the workshop.
Fax your completed reservation form to 1-310-454-2748
or e-mail to darby@ucla.edu
Your name____________________________________________________________________
Affiliation_____________________________________________________________________
Address_______________________________________________________________________
_____________________________________________________________________________
Phone no.____________________________ Fax no._____________________________
Do you need a parking permit? Yes____ No____
Will you be attending the lunch? Yes____ No____
If so, do you prefer vegetarian food? Yes____ No____
Please immediately fax any change in plans to 1-310-454-2748
or e-mail to darby@ucla.edu
Limited travel awards are available from the Biotechnology Program for University of California students, postdoctoral researchers, faculty, and staff. For applications, please call the Program office at 510-643-2584 no later than March 25, 1999.
Map to the Women's Faculty Club at the University of California-Berkeley (510-845-5084)
The Women's Faculty Club is located at C6 just northwest of the Haas School of Business at the University of California-Berkeley. The telephone number for the Club is 510-845-5084.
North
